Challenging the Saint: Criticizing Viktor Frankl and the Controversy Surrounding His Legacy

The debate over whether it is acceptable to criticize a saint has been reignited by the recent revelations about Viktor Frankl, the renowned Holocaust survivor and founder of logotherapy. In a detailed response to his critics, a historian and author reflects on his own journey of researching and writing about Frankl’s life, including the controversial aspects that have sparked controversy and outrage.

The author, who spent over 20 years researching and writing a biography of Frankl, delves into the discrepancies and omissions in Frankl’s own accounts of his life, particularly his involvement in experimental brain surgery on suicidal Jewish patients during the war. These revelations have challenged the saintly image of Frankl and raised questions about his moral integrity and legacy.

Despite facing criticism and backlash from Frankl’s followers and admirers, the author stands by his critical assessment of Frankl’s life and legacy. He argues that the truth must be told, even if it challenges the revered status of a saintly figure like Frankl. The author’s reflections on memory, identity, and the cultural implications of the Holocaust add depth to the ongoing debate about how we remember and honor historical figures like Frankl.

Ultimately, the author acknowledges the complexity of Frankl’s life and the enduring impact of his work, even as he grapples with the ethical and moral implications of his actions. The question of whether it is okay to criticize a saint remains open-ended, but the author’s thoughtful and introspective response sheds light on the challenges and responsibilities of engaging with the legacies of revered figures in history.